This past season of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills focused mostly on Erika Jayne and her drama with Tom Girardi‘s legal case. As the season was filmed, more information about Tom’s crimes became public and Erika’s costars started asking more and more questions.

Kyle Richards, who is one of Erika’s closest friends on the show, started to doubt the stories Erika was telling the group. Kyle and many of the other women noticed the gaps in Erika’s story, but Erika wasn’t willing to allow her friends to question her.

Kyle ended the season openly upset, and now she’s revealed that this is making her question whether she’ll be returning for next season.

Credit: Jean Baptiste Lacroix/Getty Images