For starters, I first found that all parts of the plastic peanut butter container is not all recyclable. “Metal lids can be removed and recycled loose in the bin. Plastic lids and caps from glass bottles and plastic jars should be thrown away.”Click to see full answer. People also ask, can you recycle used peanut butter jars?Including a jar that still has some oily material inside does not necessarily ruin an entire batch of recyclables. The dirty jar may be sorted by hand and removed from the recycling stream. Scrape out as much peanut butter as you can, then fill the jar about one-fourth full with water.Likewise, can you recycle Nutella jars? Today, Nutella uses plastic jars, rather than glass jars. These plastic jars can be disposed of at local disposal stations, or can be put in the recycling bin. The jar lids are made of a polypropylene material, which can also be recycled. Also, how do you throw out peanut butter? 9 Answers. I have found that using hot, hot water from the faucet helps to soften the peanut butter and loosen it from the jar’s edges and surface. Often times I will fill it with hot water and let it soak for 10-15 minutes or so, and then return to the jar and empty it.Should you wash jars before recycling?If empty jars, bottles, and cans have visible residue within the container, you should rinse them out before tossing them in the recycling bin.